Wednesday 13 May 2009

Guest Post: "BDSM: A Class Act?"

This guest post is by Mz. Muse (I gather this is the name she uses on Feministing, but I don't know how to find her profile to link it). It was originally posted to a locked post in her livejournal some time ago, and I offered to give it a wider audience here; after some edits and tweaks, here it is.


"BDSM: A Class Act?" by Mz. Muse


I read this article about BDSM and feminism linked off a friend's journal. I ranted about it a little in his journal, but it was still bothering me in the shower this morning (and not in the way I might like kinky feminists to bother me in the shower).

So it gets it's own ranty little post. In the above article, "The Fantasy of Acceptable Non-Consent", Stacey May Fowles puts forward the theory that BDSM culture shares culpability for creating what she calls "rape culture", a culture that normalizes violence against women. Her article is well worth reading, so don't see my recap of it as a short-cut to her own thoughts. I'm responding to just one section, in which she suggests that BDSM tropes leak into mainstream pornography. Without the benefit of careful training in the BDSM community's standards of safe, sane, consensual play, Fowles believes that young men who grow up seeing images of women bound, gagged or apparently forced into sex will enact these scenes on unwilling victims instead of enthusiastic play partners.

Fowles treads dangerously close to the anti-porn feminist position that pornography inspires rape. If that were true, logically such pornography should be banned, which leads us right down the primrose path of censorship to the lovely hell of condemning ourselves and others for thought crimes. There's also the risk of hanging our allies out to dry for being too dark and dirty, as happens so often in minority rights movements, especially sexual ones. For the most part, mainstream porn doesn't turn me on, but I still feel compelled to defend its right to exist and get others off.

Fowles talks about sexual domination of women as if BDSM invented it. For example, she refers to anything approaching rape fantasy as "desires specific to BDSM". I'd venture that the reverse is true - the desire for sexual power play prompted the creation of BDSM. Violent sex is hot. People of all genders have, I'd venture, been fantasizing about it and doing it for as long as there's been sex and power.

The Marquis de Sade, in the 1790s, eroticized rape, torture and even murder. It's from his writings that we draw our word for sexual cruelty. Masochism comes from Sacher-Masoch, who published Venus in Furs, his autobiographical account of making himself his mistress' slave in 1870.

My suspicion is that modern BDSM evolved as a way to play with fire and not get burned; it's a safety code and community that lets us do the dark things our ids beg for without exposing our polite, socialized selves to the pain of becoming either victims or brutal aggressors. Knowing about BDSM doesn't make me want to have kinky sex; being human and wired that way makes me want kinky sex. BDSM just gives me tools to do it safely.

Inside Fowles assertion that "serious BDSM practitioners" can and should be allowed to do the violent, dark things that the "average young male heterosexual" can't be trusted to even jerk off to fantasies about, I think I see a hidden class issue. It's not merely that Fowles’ BDSM culture is defined as much by expensive props and $400 leather boots as it is by the rules of safe-sane-consensual play. It's that she's missing the history of sexual aggression between classes when she asserts that we live in a modern, newly created rape culture.

Fowles is looking at BDSM tropes in the mainstream porn videos distributed on the Internet and seeing the cheap, easy access to these images as a source of "rape culture". She thinks these images suggest desires and acts to young men that otherwise they'd be blissfully ignorant of.

We have a solid literary record stretching back at least three hundred years of a culture where women were expected to maintain their virtue through chastity, young men were expected to engage in casual sex, and there was plenty of kinky porn. Probably those things have been true much longer; it’s my personal knowledge of literary history that goes back only that far, not the existence of kinky porn. If "women", by which we mean middle- and upper-class women, were all going to their marriage beds virgins, who were these guys fucking?

The servants. Prostitutes. Poor girls. These are the people de Sade was routinely accused of abusing and molesting before he was imprisoned. The people who over and over again in literature and historical record are raped, knocked up, “ruined” and cast aside by men of a higher social class who would never dream of laying an improper hand on their social peers.

I would suggest that the cultural shift which has occurred in the past few generations is not the creation of a "rape culture", but a culture in which respectable middle-class women are more likely to be targeted as victims of sexual assault by their peers, and therefore one in which rape has become more visible as a problem. I would bet that women are no more likely to be raped now than they were a century ago; in fact I bet we are on average safer from sexual assault. But the breakdown in rigid class systems and rigid sexual mores creates an atmosphere where "nice girls" are at greater risk from assault by otherwise “nice” boys.

I think the responsibility for this shift could be argued to lie with the Sexual Revolution and the accompanying wave of feminism that followed it. Around the middle of the 20th century, (I am wildly theorizing) two things happened: young middle class American men (the group I think Fowles is really talking about when she refers to "average males") stopped having access to socially sanctioned targets for sexual aggression - domestic servants have become wildly uncommon, visiting prostitutes is not part of the normal adolescent experience in the States, class barriers got a lot mushier after WWII, women's rights in general have come into public awareness to the point where raping anyone is frowned on - and young women began to claim their sexual agency and independence in a way that made them newly sexually available.

We now have a culture where young men are taught to view young women of their own class as sexual commodities, while a few generations ago they would have been brought up to view their female peers as the "angels in the house" whom they might love or marry and the lower class women in their lives as sex objects who they might fuck, with or without consent. A man growing up today learns to look to his girlfriend/wife to play out violent fantasies that he might once have satisfied with a prostitute or not at all.

This cultural shift gives us a lot of great things - sexual agency! safe, sane, consensual kink! birth control! - but with it we have all inherited some of the risk that used to belong more clearly to women on the fringes of respectable society. It's not BDSM, or its watered-down aesthetic leaking into mainstream porn, that contributes to a culture of rape.

The possibly increased risk that "nice" middle-class white women will be raped by "nice" middle-class white men is a shadowy by-product of the otherwise good work of liberal feminism and the sexual revolution in giving women more sexual agency and "leveling the playing field" as it were.

We now have a more fair, just system than in the past, where any woman can be seen to be sexually available to anyone walking down the street, instead of only certain classes, races and roles of women being seen that way. Which means that more women who otherwise might have expected to live in sexual safety are exposed to situations where they might be raped.

Similarly, men who previously could have used their power to demand sexual consent from a servant, slave or lower-class woman now have to negotiate for any sexual encounter, so more of them are exposed to charges of rape where before their behavior would have been written off as "sowing wild oats" or "boys being boys".

Also, I think more people now expect to get from their partners/spouses the kind of sexual services they would once have not dared ask for, and only expected a whore to be available for. Which again means more negotiation of the kind very few of us get good training in.

It's not that feminism is a problem per se. It's just that in solving one set of problems we've created some new ones, which we can in turn solve by doing a next layer of work on sexual consent and gender rights. I think that work is well under way. But pointing fingers outside of mainstream feminism to blame kink or porn for "rape culture" is not helping.

NOTE: I was painfully aware of the specter of race as I wrote this, but didn't feel like I had the background to do it justice without a lot more research than I was going to get done this afternoon between diaper changes.

299 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 299 of 299
Anonymous said...

buy cialis can you buy cialis mexico - buy brand cialis online no prescription

Anonymous said...

viagra 50mg cheap viagra and cialis on line - viagra online yahoo answers

Anonymous said...

buy viagra is it safe to buy viagra online yahoo answers - buy viagra online with laser card

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription viagra in us prescription required - non prescription viagra online us

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription cheap viagra new zealand - viagra for women yahoo

Anonymous said...

order cialis cialis rxlist - cialis цена

Anonymous said...

[url=http://loveepicentre.com/map.php][img]http://loveepicentre.com/uploades/photos/8.jpg[/img][/url]
sex when dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/map.php]dating spiritual[/url] dating control freak
adult dating wv [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]sex dating sites with instant message[/url] recent studies on dating
largest dating site in eaurope [url=http://loveepicentre.com/map.php]seattle lesbian dating sites[/url] who has been dating miranda cosgrove

Anonymous said...

[url=http://loveepicentre.com][img]http://loveepicentre.com/uploades/photos/8.jpg[/img][/url]
master slave dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]huntsville dating hotlines[/url] risks of online dating
limitations for using carbon 14 dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]friends dating sms people pl[/url] soperton dating
over 40 dating sacramento [url=http://loveepicentre.com/taketour.php]searching for good online dating sites[/url] modesto dating

Anonymous said...

generic viagra order viagra online canadian pharmacy - buy viagra online in nz

Anonymous said...

buy soma online generic soma pill identifier - soma drug family

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol in usa - buy tramadol personal check

Anonymous said...

buy cialis buy cialis amsterdam - cialis coupon trial

Anonymous said...

viagra online buy legit viagra online - cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy

Anonymous said...

generic viagra viagra online site reviews - where to buy generic viagra blog

Anonymous said...

buy soma online wash soma bras - effects of soma pills

Anonymous said...

[url=http://loveepicentre.com/][img]http://loveepicentre.com/uploades/photos/3.jpg[/img][/url]
100 free dating baton rouge exercise [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]hindhu dating online for singles[/url] dating services meeting single men
dating like candy store [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]dating polls[/url] dating romanian men
expat dating in netherlands [url=http://loveepicentre.com/articles.php]young russian dating[/url] dating services st paul

Anonymous said...

buy soma kendrick lamar san diego soma tickets - buy soma online cash delivery

Anonymous said...

purchase soma order hgh somatropin - buy somatropin tablets

Anonymous said...

cheapest soma prescription drug soma used - soma drug detection time

Anonymous said...

buy soma cheapest generic soma - buy somatropin europe

Anonymous said...

buy somas online buy soma online florida - buy soma pills online

Anonymous said...

soma sale where to buy soma online overnight - soma 70.3 results

Anonymous said...

discount soma buy soma 350 mg - soma standard drug test

Anonymous said...

buy soma soma medication facts - what drug is soma classified as

Anonymous said...

cheap retin-a retin a micro coupon 2012 - retin a australia buy

Anonymous said...

buy soma online soma-online.org - soma muscle relaxer 350

Anonymous said...

retin a online retin a micro wrinkles eye - retin a gel .1

Anonymous said...

buy soma soma osteopathic - soma buy

Anonymous said...

order soma street value of soma 350 mg - soma bras good

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol medication buy tramadol without a script - tramadol hcl high erowid

Anonymous said...

buy retin-a retin-a cream composition - retin a gel package insert

Anonymous said...

generic cialis cialis no prescription overnight - cialis daily tolerance

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online legal order tramadol online - buy tramadol in usa

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol no prescription overnight cod delivery - buy tramadol in usa

Anonymous said...

cheap tramadol buy tramadol online pharmacy - can you buy tramadol online in the uk

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol rx tramadol for dogs - buy tramadol cod personal check

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol 180 tramadol 50mg street - legal buy tramadol usa

Anonymous said...

cialis online no prescription viagra cialis reviews - cialis online nederland

Anonymous said...

cheap tramadol buy tramadol online without a prescription - buy tramadol order cheap tramadol online

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol for dogs - buy tramadol online reviews

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50 mg too much tramadol for dogs - order tramadol online overnight delivery

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50mg can order tramadol online legally - tramadol hcl para que serve

Anonymous said...

cheap tramadol online best place buy tramadol forum - tramadol hcl brand name

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online buy cialis online discount - generic cialis e20

Anonymous said...

cheap tramadol tramadol 50 mg info - buy tramadol online cod no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol 100mg effects of tramadol overdose - tramadol online apotheke

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol rx buy tramadol safely - tramadol 100mg online

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol overnight tramadol quetiapine - tramadol snort

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax tablets online - xanax xr

Anonymous said...

generic xanax 0.25 xanax and alcohol - generic xanax pills look like

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax withdrawal day 3 - xanax dosage how often

Anonymous said...

buy cheap tramadol tramadol dosage dogs - tramadol online

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax dosage compared valium - xanax side effects jaw pain

Anonymous said...

tramadol online tramadol premature ejaculation - tramadol withdrawal day 2

Anonymous said...

buy generic tramadol online can you buy tramadol in usa - buy tramadol online pharmacy

Anonymous said...

tramadol 100mg tramadol hcl 50 mg strength - tramadol hexal 100 mg

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online without a prescription tramadol zydus 50 mg - buy tramadol usa

Anonymous said...

generic xanax generic to xanax - xanax side effects breastfeeding

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax xr pills - buy greenstone xanax

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol overnight shipping buy tramadol online next day delivery - tramadol hcl picture

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol dosage nz - how to order tramadol online

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol drug carisoprodol long term effects - carisoprodol drug screen

Anonymous said...

buy cialis soft tabs cialis quickly does work - cialis daily women

Anonymous said...

alprazolam xanax generic xanax look like - 2mg of xanax and alcohol

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax weed high - xanax side effects anger

Anonymous said...

cialis sale levitra versus cialis reviews - buy legit cialis online

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax dosage night - xanax and alcohol drugs forum

Anonymous said...

discount cialis how to buy cialis online from usa - cialis online no prescription overnight

Anonymous said...

cheap cialis online cialis refractory period - cialis for bph reviews

Anonymous said...

cheap tadalafil cialis daily safe - cialis half life

Anonymous said...

buy cialis no prescription canada cialis online paypal - cialis cost walmart

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol 93/58 - tramadol hcl 37.5-3

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol dosage in humans - tramadol rx purchase

Anonymous said...

These are genuіnelу enoгmous ideas in concегning blogging.
Yоu have touсhed somе fastidious factoгs
heге. Any wаy keeр
up wrinting.

Fеel freе to ѕuгf to my homepage: Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

Thеse are genuinely enormous ideas іn conсегnіng blogging.
You have touched some fаstidious faсtors here.
Anу way keep up wгinting.

Fеel free to surf to my blog Chemietoilette
Also see my website: Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

klonopin sale klonopin quickly does work - roche klonopin 2mg

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online how to get klonopin out of your system - klonopin zyprexa

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online how long does 2mg klonopin last - klonopin withdrawal lamictal

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol buy tramadol no prescription cheap - tramadol use addiction

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol in florida tramadol high blood pressure - tramadol hcl 50 mg for migraines

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50 tramadol to buy with no prescription - buy tramadol

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online klonopin zoloft mixing - klonopin jaw clenching

Anonymous said...

http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#3081 buy clonazepam online canada - dose of klonopin for anxiety

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol with paypal tramadol 60 mg - generic tramadol online no prescription

Anonymous said...

order klonopin online average dose of klonopin for anxiety - how does klonopin get you high

Anonymous said...

http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#cheap ativan klonopin social anxiety - klonopin for driving anxiety

Anonymous said...

Салон Секреты Красоты предлагает большой выбор классических салонных услуг: парикмахерские услуги, маникюр, педикюр, косметология, перманентный макияж. Мы работаем более 10 лет и придерживаемся принципа соотношения цены и качества обслуживания. Для постоянных клиентов действуют акции и бонусная система. Заходите на наш сайт [url=http://s-krasoti.ru/] пилинг в домашних условиях
[/url]

Anonymous said...

http://southcarolinaaccidentattorney.com/#61879 muscle relaxant soma carisoprodol - carisoprodol 350 mg review

Anonymous said...

only like any emblematic gaming internet site In that location which you can redeem in the cashier section of the casino one time you Feature registered an News report. [url=http://www.tasty-onlinecasino.co.uk/]online casino[/url] online casino Will you find the gorillas the bonuses, which gives you a estimable estimate of what is left field of the requirements that you mustiness converge. http://www.onlinecasinotaste.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

у нас на этом веб-сайте можно взглянуть на громадный набор умных статей о [url=http://www.rk-37.ru/]уход за кожей 30[/url].

Anonymous said...

Производственная компания «М-СЕТ» специализируется на производстве сварных сеток в рулонах, имеющих широкое применение в различных строительных работах.
Производство сварной сетки выполняется на многоточечных сварных машинах, методом контактно-точечной сварки крестообразных соединений. Все пересечения и стыки прутьев тщательно сварены, благодаря чему конструкция отличается превосходным качеством и является одной из самых прочных.
На нашем сайте Вы можете посмотреть образцы нашей продукции и связаться с нами
[url=http://setka-vlg.ru/]укрепить кирпичную кладку
[/url]

Anonymous said...

It's done this way in case of anchored loan from the lender to defend his awareness [url=http://www.ubyvk.co.uk/]12 month loans[/url] http://www.your12monthloans.co.uk/ If Republican institutions the first are focused on cutting administration spending, you have to take a closer look at the Department of Defense http://www.your12monthloans.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

So if around Octad half decks or quadruplet full decks are remaining and your incontrovertible linear matter is is because these are, "utility machines." [url=http://www.yqilh.co.uk/]online casino uk[/url] online casinos PhillI Have got now been their cognition in their ledger, How to Win at casino australia. http://www.yqilh.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online with mastercard buy tramadol cod online - buy tramadolultram

Anonymous said...

http://www.achildsplace.org/banners/tramadolonline/#9536 tramadol 100 - order tramadol online without prescription

Anonymous said...

Is by using soak business! The current coffeemaker truly Bad Decker merchandise that are likely to serve you for a months.
That is the piece you may then act on. Notice the inflammation
component shrink tummy.

My web page commercial coffee brewer by mr coffee

Anonymous said...

here on the web blog assembled a wide range of interesting articles on the [url=http://apple-televizor.ru/]http://apple-televizor.ru/[/url]

Anonymous said...

Let's take a have time-tested well-nigh every matter and are not any more Concerned in acquiring into human relationship. [url=http://www.kimchiya.com/cgi-bin/bbs/minibbs.cgi]Continued[/url] Read More Here Government and UN troops worked to sufficient to win it, regardless of who seems in ascendence? http://codecry.com/content/how-protect-your-dwelling-wintertime-weather

yanmaneee said...

jordan 6
nike air vapormax
jordan retro
nike air max
converse
adidas yeezy
adidas yeezy
off white jordan 1
kyrie 6
yeezy boost 350 v2

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 299 of 299   Newer› Newest»