Sunday, 11 May 2008

Polymorphous Perversity: On the UK's new pornography law

More on the UK law, this from a legal perspective (but by a USian as well)

Polymorphous Perversity: On the UK's new pornography law

The UK has now passed a law to criminalize the possession of "violent" and "extreme" pornography. A mother who blamed her daughter's murder on pornography involving strangulation campaigned for the law. You can read the language of the law here, you may also find of interest this website, of a group opposing the law. The most pertinent language is this: covered material includes material that "explicitly and realistically" depicts "an which which threatens a person's life," or "an act which results, or is likely to result, in serious injury to a person's anus, breasts or genitals."

It strikes me that the terms "threatens a person's life," "likely to result," and "serious injury" make it possible to interpret this law as criminalizing large chunks of BDSM pornography, i.e., material that is produced by and for consenting adults and that (though it may technically fit the above definition) when understood in context, is not intended to be viewed as depicting and does not otherwise promote actual violence. Examples: erotic knifeplay, simulated choking, and the ever-popular CBT (not cognitive-behavioral therapy - look it up).

Particularly remarkable is that, unlike U.S. obscenity laws, but like child pornography laws, the law criminalizes not only production and distribution but possession. Having forbidden images on your hard drive could land you in jail.

This raises in my mind the applicability of the UK Human Rights Act and through it the European Convention on Human Rights. These documents have not been consistently and broadly applied in the area of sexual privacy - witness the European Court's upholding of the Spanner convictions.

Interestingly and disturbingly, the UK Government cited the Spanner case in its justification of the law:

The material to be covered by this new offence is at the most extreme end of the spectrum of pornographic material which is likely to be thought abhorrent by most people. It is not possible at law to give consent to the type of activity covered by the offence, so it is therefore likely that a criminal offence is being committed where the activity which appears to be taking place is actually taking place. The House of Lords upheld convictions for offences of causing actual and grievous bodily harm in the case of
Brown [1994] 1 AC 212 which involved a group of sado-masochists who had engaged in consensual torture. The threshold that the clauses have set is very high, so while those taking part might argue that they had consented to it, such consent is not valid at law.

Once one concludes - as the House of Lords did a decade ago, that BDSM is itself a crime, criminalizing its depiction, and even possession of such depictions, becomes easy. The justification, vis a vis the right to freedom of speech, is identical to that regarding child pornography: the forbidden material is the record of a violent crime, and its dissemination furthers the harm to the victim of that crime, and feeds a market for further crimes. This is the rationale on which the US Supreme Court has upheld the child pornography laws, and without knowing the corresponding case law in the UK or the European Court of Human Rights, I would expect a similar result here when the law is, inevitably, challenged in court.

280 comments:

1 – 200 of 280   Newer›   Newest»
Jennifer said...

In case anyone's interested... I wrote a (longish) response to the UK government's consultation on this at the end of 2005, and stuck a copy on the web here.

Re-reading it now, I notice I didn't say much about the "appears to be..." bit (i.e. including pictures where the action was simulated). I could have made more of that angle in the context of "protecting the participants". But other than that I think it was quite a good taking-to-bits of the ill-conceived nature of the idea.

And yeah, all a v depressing episode with common sense in short supply.

pcsolotto said...

Thanks to the owner of this blog. Ive enjoyed reading this topic.

Anonymous said...

and the particular unusual footnote 8, wherever she Cheap D3 Goldbasically crams your ex total controversy, the girl states that festival/conference managers have to make selections for folks, since wanting to work by means of opinion ensures that those people who are as well *charismatic* or perhaps *too good at arguing* mayCheap GW2 Gold possibly in any other case get your day.

Anonymous said...

order ativan online ativan to sleep - ativan no effect

Anonymous said...

cheap tramadol online stop tramadol addiction - side effects of tramadol 50mg tablets

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol saturday delivery tramadol fass 100mg - tramadol seizures

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tablets buy tramadol online from usa - tramadol 50 mg half life

Anonymous said...

purchase tramadol tramadol online overnight mastercard - tramadol normal dosage

Anonymous said...

buy ativan online signs of ativan addiction - ativan uses depression

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol without a script tramadol constipation - tramadol make you high

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol high blood pressure medication - tramadol withdrawal cold turkey

Anonymous said...

cheap tramadol no prescription tramadol hydrochloride 50 mg effects - tramadol 100mg for sale

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online cheap buy ultram online no prescription overnight - buy ultram online with no prescription

Anonymous said...

generic lorazepam buy lorazepam online india - lorazepam normon 1mg 50 comprimidos efg

Anonymous said...

tramadol online can you buy tramadol in spain - buy tramadol overnight delivery no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol does tramadol 50 mg do you - tramadol hcl 50 mg what is it used for

Anonymous said...

buy cheap klonopin klonopin dosage instructions - klonopin qtc prolongation

Anonymous said...

order tramadol no prescription tramadol листовка - tramadol withdrawal help

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online cheap klonopin in system - .25 mg klonopin side effects

Anonymous said...

ativan for anxiety ativan ep 904 - lorazepam 1 mg buy uk

Anonymous said...

where to buy tramadol tramadol online shipped to florida - buy tramadol online for dogs

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online cheap buy tramadol no prescription 100 mg - side effects tramadol hci 50mg

Anonymous said...

klonopin without prescriptions where can i buy klonopin online - combining klonopin and alcohol

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol buy online - tramadol kali 083

Anonymous said...

zolpidem drug recreational use of ambien cr - can you buy ambien over the counter

Anonymous said...

tramadol cheap tramadol 50mg for pain - tramadol hcl generic name

Anonymous said...

generic soma online soma pills street price - buy cheap soma online no prescription

Anonymous said...

lorazepam no prescription ativan side effects erowid - ativan withdrawal youtube

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online cheap tramadol dose vet - can tramadol hcl 50 mg be cut in half

Anonymous said...

tramadol online how to purchase tramadol online - buy tramadol from usa

Anonymous said...

order klonopin online klonopin 2mg pics - que es la klonopin

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online what does tramadol 50 mg do to you - buy tramadol india

Anonymous said...

tramadol 100mg generic tramadol online - tramadol dosage grasscity

Anonymous said...

generic ativan online lorazepam 1mg para que serve - ativan dosage for insomnia

Anonymous said...

online soma soma institute - cheap soma sale

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol cod get cheap tramadol - tramadol hydrochloride buy online

Anonymous said...

ambien medication ambien sleep aid wiki - ambien 6.5 cr

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol medication tramadol addiction constipation - can i buy tramadol online legally

Anonymous said...

klonopin buy klonopin withdrawal or anxiety - is it legal to buy klonopin online

Anonymous said...

order soma online buy watson brand soma online - soma san diego side stage

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol hcl 627 - tramadol liver

Anonymous said...

buy soma who carries soma bras - buy somatropin pen

Anonymous said...

order tramadol tramadol online pharmacy usa - tramadol high

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online no prescription overnight buy tramadol online no prescription usa - tramadol hcl xr 200 mg

Anonymous said...

order klonopin online klonopin and xanax together - klonopin dosage vs xanax

Anonymous said...

tramadol online no prescription tramadol 50 mg classification - need to purchase tramadol

Anonymous said...

cheap soma soma vanishing edge bras - soma drug slang

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online no prescription tramadol hcl no prescription - really cheap tramadol

Anonymous said...

ativan online ativan online - ativan juice

Anonymous said...

ambien without prescription cheapest ambien no prescription - ambien side effects weakness

Anonymous said...

order tramadol online buy tramadol online usa - tramadol 50mg for dogs and humans

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online reviews tramadol highest dosage - buy tramadol 50mg online

Anonymous said...

generic ambien generic ambien less effective - ambien cr withdrawal side effects

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol-online.biz - tramadol dosage per kg

Anonymous said...

buy soma much do soma cost street - soma embraceable bra

Anonymous said...

can you buy ambien online long will sleep ambien - ambien cr what is it

Anonymous said...

generic ambien buy ambien sleep study results - zolpidem tartrate er same ambien cr

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online high does klonopin get you - klonopin depression

Anonymous said...

zolpidem 10 mg ambien cr and alcohol - generic ambien pill identifier

Anonymous said...

ambien without a rx insomnia after taking ambien - ambien no prescription canada

Anonymous said...

order clonazepam klonopin overdose dogs - buy klonopin canada

Anonymous said...

buy viagra las vegas where to buy viagra online yahoo answers - buy real viagra online

Anonymous said...

viagra online buy cheap viagra mexico - order viagra online overnight delivery

Anonymous said...

soma online safe place buy soma online - soma neuron

Anonymous said...

generic ambien ambien much get high - generic ambien not working

Anonymous said...

can you buy viagra at walmart buy viagra online overnight shipping - viagra first time dosage

Anonymous said...

clonazepam no prescription 2mg klonopin wafer - 2mg klonopin recreational

Anonymous said...

buy ambien no prescription ambien high - ambien cr backorder

Anonymous said...

buy viagra in chicago generic viagra capsules - buy viagra online usa

Anonymous said...

soma carisoprodol soma clothing online - soma san diego crystal castles

Anonymous said...

discount viagra viagra online free shipping - viagra substitute

Anonymous said...

ambien sleep medication ambien on sale - sleeping pill alternative to ambien

Anonymous said...

buy viagra online generic viagra effectiveness - cheap viagra for women

Anonymous said...

buy viagra online legally does viagra work drunk - purchase viagra online with prescription

Anonymous said...

cheapest viagra viagra for women alternatives - buy cheap viagra online us

Anonymous said...

generic ambien ambien side effects paranoia - ambien vs xanax insomnia

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online side effects for klonopin - klonopin green pill

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol with paypal buy tramadol no prescription overnight - tramadol high 50 mg

Anonymous said...

buy ambien online pharmacy prices for ambien - ambien weed high

Anonymous said...

buy viagra buy viagra online with no prescription - where to buy viagra online australia

Anonymous said...

order sildenafil viagra 2 chainz instrumental - buy viagra online next day delivery uk

Anonymous said...

cheap ambien ambien generic walmart - ambien side effects heart palpitations

Anonymous said...

buy viagra online buy viagra jelly online - viagra online overnight shipping

Anonymous said...

viagra no prescription overnight delivery cialis vs viagra dosage - buy pink viagra women

Anonymous said...

viagra online viagra dosage per day - generic viagra online cheapest

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol faq - tramadol online paypal

Anonymous said...

buy viagra no prescription order cheap viagra online canada - generic viagra shipped to canada

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online where to buy tramadol online - buy tramadol 180

Anonymous said...

buy viagra does viagra work for paraplegics - cheap viagra 100mg uk

Anonymous said...

buy cialis 10mg cialis online doctor - cialis 40 mg dose

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol online order soma online usa - soma pharmacy no prescription

Anonymous said...

viagra online no prescriptions generic viagra blog - buy viagra for women

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol for dogs generic - tramadol 100mg buzz

Anonymous said...

buy viagra 100mg viagra x-ray - order pink viagra online

Anonymous said...

order viagra prescription order viagra 100 mg mastercard - illegal to buy viagra online

Anonymous said...

viagra online viagra duration - buy real viagra online canada

Anonymous said...

cheap cialis online cialis online usa - where to buy cialis online yahoo answers

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50 tramadol hcl 30 - tramadol 50mg and hydrocodone

Anonymous said...

buy viagra online when is generic viagra going to be available - viagra high blood pressure

Anonymous said...

buy viagra 50mg viagra recreational use - where to buy generic viagra online

Anonymous said...

order tramadol online tramadol for dogs - tramadol 50mg biogaran

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol 100mg online long does tramadol high last - tramadol withdrawal effexor

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol without prescriptions generic drug for tramadol - tramadol 100 mg side effects

Anonymous said...

order viagra from canada buy viagra no prescription cheap - does viagra work after prostate surgery

Anonymous said...

cialis online can i buy cialis over the counter - buy cialis com

Anonymous said...

generic propecia online is buying propecia online real - propecia without prescriptions

Anonymous said...

buy strattera online generic strattera in usa - strattera medication children

Anonymous said...

order cialis no prescription buy cheap cialis link online - cialis price egypt

Anonymous said...

buy retin-a retin a micro gel canadian pharmacy - retin-a cream 0.05 for acne scars

Anonymous said...

can you buy tramadol online tramadol migraine - tramadol 50 mg a normal dose

Anonymous said...

cheap cialis cialis циалис - 20 mg cialis daily use

Anonymous said...

purchase tramadol buy tramadol generic ultram - best place buy tramadol forum

Anonymous said...

cheap viagra pills buy generic viagra online in u.s - cheap viagra women

Anonymous said...

tramadol online tramadol for dogs post surgery - buy tramadol dogs usa

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol for dogs with arthritis - tramadol 100 mg street value

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol overnight cod buy tramadol rx online - tramadol 50 mg drug facts

Anonymous said...

buy retin-a online retin-a cvs - retin a wrinkles months

Anonymous said...

buy viagra 100mg online prescription viagra buy online - order viagra online from canada

Anonymous said...

finasteride hair loss propecia varicocele - propecia 90 day supply price

Anonymous said...

cialis online cialis patent expiration - cialis online authentic

Anonymous said...

buy viagra online no rx buy viagra in canada no prescription - viagra without prescriptions illegal

Anonymous said...

buy strattera online buy generic strattera - dosage de strattera

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol 50mg vs tylenol 3 - tramadol 100mg online overnight

Anonymous said...

order tramadol online cod tramadol ultram eq 50 mg - tramadol itching

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online can you buy tramadol online no prescription - generic brand name tramadol

Anonymous said...

propecia mg propecia side effects sperm - propecia side effects on liver

Anonymous said...

order tramadol overnight buy tramadol online without script - tramadol for dogs side effects

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol hcl extended release - tramadol hydrochloride 50mg high

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol overnight shipping cheap-tramadol.org - tramadol 50mg for animals

Anonymous said...

buy propecia online much does propecia cost boots - how to buy propecia in australia

Anonymous said...

retin a buy retin a micro janssen - buy retin a micro gel

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol for dogs tramadol withdrawal symptoms usa - buy tramadol online dogs

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50mg tramadol 50 mg for back pain - tramadol withdrawal symptoms dizziness

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol overdose reversal - tramadol 50 mg hydrochloride

Anonymous said...

buy propecia online generic propecia in us - belgravia centre propecia cost

Anonymous said...

buy atomoxetine online strattera 60 mg dosage - strattera dosage at night

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol hcl-acetaminophen zen - tramadol hcl 50 mg overdose

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online without a prescription ordertramadolonline - dangers tramadol addiction

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol overnight delivery no prescription - purchase tramadol no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol cod next day delivery buy tramadol online with visa - tramadol for dogs after surgery

Anonymous said...

cheap tramadol online tramadol 50 mg good - tramadol dosage depression

Anonymous said...

tramadol without prescription tramadol withdrawal vs. suboxone withdrawal - buy tramadol online legally

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol overnight cod tramadol addiction management - buy tramadol in europe

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online can order tramadol online legally - best place to buy tramadol online reviews

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50 mg tramadol purchase online usa - tramadol dosage equivalent

Anonymous said...

buy strattera online cheap strattera no prescription - strattera medication class

Anonymous said...

tramadol online cod tramadol rx purchase - tramadol back pain

Anonymous said...

strattera price strattera long term effects - generic strattera patent

Anonymous said...

tramadol online tramadol 50 mg and beer - tramadol withdrawal for dogs

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online no prescription overnight buy tramadol online cod overnight - tramadol dosage 15 lb dog

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol good place buy tramadol online - buy tramadol no prescription uk

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50 mg tramadol hcl 50 mg street value - 350 mg tramadol high

Anonymous said...

finasteride medication results from propecia - buy generic propecia mastercard

Anonymous said...

buy retin-a online can you buy retin-a - retin a cream 60g

Anonymous said...

tramadol online generic version tramadol - where can you buy tramadol online

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50mg is tramadol hcl 50 mg extended release - tramadol hcl gluten

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol 650 - tramadol uss ship no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy cheap propecia buy generic propecia cheap - cheap propecia finasteride

Anonymous said...

tramadol online buy tramadol online 100mg - purchase tramadol cod shipping

Anonymous said...

viagra 100mg buy viagra from australia - what is a high dosage of viagra

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50mg buy online texas tramadol - tramadol 50 mg 60 capsulas

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription generic viagra next day delivery us - buy cheap viagra online us

Anonymous said...

cheapest viagra how to purchase viagra in us - viagra buy no prescription us

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50 mg tramadol for dogs vs rimadyl - tramadol dosage maximum

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription buy viagra in us - viagra online us

Anonymous said...

buy cialis cialis drug coupon - cialis price in malaysia

Anonymous said...

generic cialis buying cialis online canada - buy viagra cialis online

Anonymous said...

generic viagra can you buy viagra online safely - buy viagra 100mg

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol m t7 - legal buy tramadol online usa

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol buy tramadol overnight delivery - reliable online pharmacy tramadol

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription cheap viagra 100mg australia - buy viagra online legally

Anonymous said...

cheap viagra buy cheap generic viagra online - viagra pill dosage

Anonymous said...

generic viagra viagra ingredients - buy generic viagra us

Anonymous said...

buy cialis generic cialis online pharmacy - cialis price amazon

Anonymous said...

generic viagra purchase viagra no prescription - buy cheap brand viagra online

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription something like viagra for women - viagra 70 years plus men

Anonymous said...

generic viagra viagra online - buy cheap viagra no prescription

Anonymous said...

cheap viagra viagra buy women - generic viagra online pharmacy us

Anonymous said...

buy viagra safest online pharmacy viagra - viagra online 24 ore

Anonymous said...

generic cialis small order cialis - cheap legitimate cialis

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online pharmacy for cialis - order cheap cialis online

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription cheap viagra levitra cialis - why not to buy generic viagra

Anonymous said...

cialis 20mg buy brand cialis no prescription - cialis price compared to viagra

Anonymous said...

buy cialis from canada cialis daily reviews - cialis price increase

Anonymous said...

generic cialis cialis black reviews - buy cialis usa

Anonymous said...

viagra price buy generic viagra online us - viagra beer

Anonymous said...

generic cialis buy cialis from europe - buy cialis without perscription

Anonymous said...

cheapest cialis cialis online australia - cialis and bph

Anonymous said...

buy soma online soma muscle relaxer 2410 - soma san diego two door cinema

Anonymous said...

buy cialis cialis online yahoo - cialis 27 90

Anonymous said...

buy soma online buy soma online cod - can order soma online legally

Anonymous said...

buy cialis cialis daily use review - cialis recreational

Anonymous said...

buy soma drug classification of soma - cheap soma online

Anonymous said...

soma drug soma cube online game - online soma cube

Anonymous said...

cialis online pharmacy generic cialis kaufen - cheap cialis 40 mg

Anonymous said...

online soma methadone soma drug interactions - soma korean

Anonymous said...

soma without prescription soma drug movie - do they test soma drug test

Anonymous said...

buy soma buy soma online cod - soma 350 mg generic

Anonymous said...

viagra online viagra online us no prescription - buy liquid viagra us

Anonymous said...

viagra online viagra online trusted - buy-viagra-us.net

«Oldest ‹Older   1 – 200 of 280   Newer› Newest»